| Evaluating and Appraising Irrigation Rights |

The prices below do not reflect the current market, but the theories are timeless.
Prior to the formation of the Northern Colorado Water Conservancy District, the appraisal of an irrigation right for cash was difficult. Conservancy District Water can be sold and transferred from Boulder, Colorado to the Fort Morgan and Brush areas. Thus, countless condemnation lawsuits have been avoided as the population of northern Colorado more than tripled in size, by the purchase of Northern Colorado Conservancy District water to implement increased domestic demand.
Big "T" water is thus the common denominator in the appraisal of water rights for cash value. Its ease of transfer makes it the biggest bargain,
Likewise, water rights which can be used by municipalities or domestic water companies are more valuable than those which cannot be used. Irrigation water which has a point of diversion upstream from a municipality is always a target for purchase by a burgeoning municipality. If a particular irrigation company water right also has storage facilities, the demand for it will be greater.
In our appraisals for the purpose of resale of water rights on a speculative basis, we assign the present market value of Big "T" water at 100%. Then, if another water right is being sought by one or more municipalities, we analyze it as follows.
1. Does the irrigation right have a sufficiently early decree so as to deliver water through the entire irrigating season? (from May through the middle of September)
2. Does the water right have storage facilities so as to guarantee late supplemental water?
If the water right meets those two qualifications, we subtract 33% from the value of Big "T" water on current sales and assign that amount of money for each acre-foot of average delivery. The ease and wide range of possible delivery of Big '"T" water is well worth the 33% premium.
Let's set up a typical example. Larimer Count Ditch, which is owned and operated by Water Supply and Storage Company of Fort Collins, Colorado meets all the qualifications of a prime water right as demanded by municipalities and domestic water companies. Water Supply and Storage Company stock will deliver about 100 acre-feet of water for every share of stock. One unit of Big "T" will deliver 1 acre-foot of water. (However, it should be noted that Big "T" has delivered as low as .70 acre-feet of water per unit)
Thus, with Big "T" at its present value of $1,600.00 per unit, Water Supply and Storage Company stock would be worth $160,000.00 per share at a par with Big "T". Taking the formula of knocking off 33% in evaluating other irrigation water, we multiply $160,000.00 x .33 which equals $52,800.00. Subtract that from $180,000.00. $160,000.00 - $52,800.00 equals $107,200.00 for one share of Water Supply and Storage.
We would make a considerable wager that the price for one share of Tater Supply and Storage Company stock is near that figure on November 11, 1978.
At any rate, we have advised purchasers and participated in land deals using that formula of appraisal and have never made an unwise move.
What about water for irrigation purposes only?
The irrigation water value is tied to several factors First of all; if you want to grow grass or hay, you can get by on much less water than if you intend to grow beets or corn. If you wish to grow truck garden crops, you need more water than for any other agricultural use. If you have a heavy clay and loam soil, you need less water than if you have sandy soil. If you are going to pump your water from your ditch and sprinkle irrigate, you will need less water than if you ditch irrigate.
Some crops are expected to produce $200.00 per acre. Crops like onions, carrots and cabbage can produce several thousands of dollars per acre if the market is right. The value of your irrigation water to you will be in the exact proportion to the crops you expect and desire to raise.
You will note in perusing the data on each right that there is an average first day that water can be used and a last day for the use of water. Then, there will be a figure for the number of days water can be used during the irrigating season. Those are of prime importance. Also, there will be a standing in the list of priorities. That too can be of great significance. However, don't rely on the standing in the list of priorities too much. Companies with an adequate storage system are many times considerably better off than the companies with early decrees and no storage facilities.
Beware of water rights which have a last day for delivery during July or August. Sometimes, we assign a value of only 20% of the current price of Big "T" water because of the that the ditch or company cannot deliver any water during the hot mid-summer period.
Another thing to remember though is that the municipalities in northern Colorado are trying to accumulate water so as to be amply supplied for the next 50 years. Thus, many of the cities have water to lease at the present time. Big "T" water can be leased for from $5.50 to $10.00 per acre-foot. By leasing of Big 'T" water, one can be assured of getting along with a poor water right for a good number of years. At best though, the leasing solution is only temporary.
Always remember that the value of land in northern Colorado is directly related to the quality, and quantity of its water right.
back to top